For the discerning aficionado, navigating the extensive portfolio of Habanos can be a delightful challenge. Few brands command as much historical respect as H. Upmann, and within their portfolio, the Magnum line stands as a beacon of modern excellence. When smokers find themselves debating h. upmann magnum 46 and 50 - comparing two exceptional vitolas, they are essentially choosing between two distinct philosophies of smoking pleasure. Both cigars offer a window into the prestigious world of Cuban cigars, yet they diverge in format, intensity, and evolution. In this comprehensive guide, we break down the nuances of these two giants to help you select the perfect addition to your humidor.
The Legacy of H. Upmann and the Magnum Line
Founded in 1844 by Hermann Upmann, a German banker with a passion for tobacco, the H. Upmann brand has survived revolutions, embargoes, and changing market tastes to remain one of the most sought-after habanos in the world. Historically known for a milder, elegant profile, the brand took a decisive turn in the mid-2000s with the introduction of the Magnum series.
The Magnum 50 was initially released as a Limited Edition in 2005 before becoming a permanent addition to the regular lineup due to overwhelming popularity. Its success proved that H. Upmann could deliver a cigar with the complexity and body to rival the heavyweights of the industry. Following this triumph, the H. Upmann Magnum 46 was introduced to regular production in 2016, offering a slightly different take on the blend in a classic Corona Gorda format. Today, both cigars are considered benchmarks for quality construction and flavor consistency.
Detailed Breakdown: H. Upmann Magnum 46
The Magnum 46 is often described by seasoned smokers as the "connoisseur's choice." It adheres to the Corona Gorda vitola, a format that many purists argue provides the ideal ratio between the wrapper and the filler, resulting in a more nuanced flavor profile.
Construction and Specifications
Measuring 5 5/8 inches (143mm) in length with a ring gauge of 46, the Magnum 46 is a beautifully proportioned cigar. It features the signature pigtail cap found on the Magnum line, adding a touch of artisanal flair. The wrapper is typically a stunning caramel-brown color, oily to the touch, and seamless in its construction.
Tasting Notes and Smoking Experience
Upon lighting, the Magnum 46 immediately distinguishes itself from its larger sibling. While it shares the brand’s characteristic smoothness, the flavor profile is more restrained and sophisticated.
- First Third: Expect a gentle introduction with notes of dry wood, cedar, and a subtle nuttiness reminiscent of fresh-roasted hazelnuts.
- Second Third: As the smoke settles, distinct flavors of cocoa powder and leather emerge, balanced by a creamy texture.
- Final Third: The finish brings a touch of white pepper and spice, but never overwhelms the palate.
The draw is typically impeccable, offering a cool smoke that allows the complexity of the Cuban cigars to shine without becoming harsh. This is a cigar that rewards slow, contemplative smoking, making it ideal for a morning pairing with coffee or an early evening indulgence.
Detailed Breakdown: H. Upmann Magnum 50
In contrast to the refined elegance of the 46, the H. Upmann Magnum 50 is a powerhouse of flavor. As a Robustos Extra, it offers a wider ring gauge, which changes the smoking dynamic significantly by allowing for a cooler burn and a greater volume of smoke per puff.
Construction and Specifications
The Magnum 50 measures 5 7/8 inches (150mm) with a ring gauge of 50. This extra thickness provides a firm feel in the hand and ensures the cigar burns slowly. Like the 46, it is finished with a flawless cap and utilizes the finest tobacco from the Vuelta Abajo region.
Tasting Notes and Smoking Experience
The Magnum 50 is widely celebrated for its rich, robust character. It is a medium-to-full-bodied smoke that delivers flavor from the very first inch.
- First Third: Opens with bold notes of earth, espresso, and a distinct sweetness that hints at dark chocolate.
- Second Third: The flavor profile deepens, introducing toasted bread, cinnamon, and a creaminess that coats the palate.
- Final Third: A crescendo of leather, black pepper, and mineral notes provides a long, satisfying finish.
Because of the larger ring gauge, the Magnum 50 tends to be smoother and cooler than the 46, muting some of the sharper spice notes in favor of a rich, velvety texture. This makes it an excellent choice for pairing with aged rum or a single malt whisky.
Comparing the Experience: Which Should You Choose?
When h. upmann magnum 46 and 50 - comparing two exceptional vitolas, the decision often comes down to personal preference regarding smoking time and flavor intensity.
Flavor Intensity vs. Nuance
The Magnum 50 is the bolder of the two. Its larger ring gauge allows for a more complex blend of filler tobaccos, resulting in a richer, fuller smoke. If you prefer a cigar that makes a statement with thick, creamy smoke and pronounced flavors of coffee and chocolate, the 50 is the superior choice. Conversely, the Magnum 46 is about precision. Its thinner format highlights the wrapper leaf more prominently, offering a more nuanced, "classic" Havana experience with distinct herbal and woody notes.
Smoking Duration
Time is a crucial factor for the modern smoker. The Magnum 46, being slightly shorter and thinner, typically offers a smoking time of about 45 to 60 minutes. The Magnum 50, due to its girth and length, is a commitment, often requiring 60 to 75 minutes to fully enjoy. If you are short on time, the 46 is the practical choice; if you have an afternoon to relax, the 50 provides a longer, more leisurely burn.
Aging Potential
Both habanos possess excellent aging potential. H. Upmann cigars are renowned for improving significantly with time. The Magnum 50’s robust structure allows it to age gracefully for decades, softening its initial strength into a complex symphony of tertiary flavors. The Magnum 46 also ages beautifully, with the leather and spice notes mellowing into a refined, elegant smoke.
Buying Advice and Storage
When purchasing these Cuban cigars, always ensure you are buying from a reputable source to guarantee authenticity. Both the Magnum 46 and Magnum 50 are highly sought after, making them targets for counterfeiters.
For storage, aim for a relative humidity of 65-70%. Given the thicker ring gauge of the Magnum 50, it can be slightly more forgiving of humidity fluctuations, but proper storage is essential to preserve the essential oils that give these cigars their distinct flavor profiles.
Ultimately, there is no wrong choice between these two. The Magnum 46 offers a refined, classic journey, while the Magnum 50 delivers a rich, modern indulgence. For the true enthusiast, the best advice is to box both and enjoy the unique character of
